Fenicci's of Hershey

I can't give an overly detailed review since we only ordered pizza. Pizza was good, my son had spagetti and meatballs from the kids menu which was good, they gave him a good portion. My only complaint is the cups at the table didn't seem to be clean and one had a lipstick stain which was promptly replaced by the nice waitress.

Nice quiet atmosphere, we were seated right away when we checked in for our reservation. Food was amazing, mushroom appetizer had the best juice, soaked in the bread.mmmm! Chicken piccata my favorite, lemon gelato for dessert rounded out a perfect meal. Can't wait to go back and try more!

Always a good time and great food and drink. Phil runs an outstanding establishment, an upscale neighborhood hangout! Upside down pizza is the best! Enjoy!

Ordered takeout and we were not disappointed! The basil seafood alfredo was SO good! I could not stop eating it and soaking up the amazing sauce with bread. We also ordered two pizzas (bruschetta and meat lovers) both were delicious! Would definitely return.

Sadly very disappointing. Menu looked great, but it's didn't live up to it. All of the pasta dishes were TOO aldante. Sauces were lacking flavor and seasoning/salt. Very bland. Service was mediocre at best.

Veal was a large portion, sauce was great, salad was large. If veal had of been pounded it have been superb.

Outstanding flavors and a wide selection of meals. Great staff and atmosphere. Please visit or curb side it. Enjoy. Happy New Year.

Quality food, diverse menu, modern classy food display, a bit pricey. A little slow with counter service.

Ordered double pepperoni pizza. My pizza came out with 2 pepperoni per slice. The waiter went to ask the cook what happened. Cook said that was their quota of pepperoni. We all looked at the pizza including the waiter and laughed. They charged me for the extra pepperoni. My family's from Hershey so not new to the restaurant. Hope bad food from them will not become the norm. It was always my go to for food done right. Lots of new restaurants across the street.

Great Italian restaurant in the heart of the sweetest place place on earth.there are known for lasagna, and if you finish, they give you a certificate.

Wonderful place for our family’s girl’s dinner. Wonderful food, waiter and atmosphere. Highly recommend Finiccis.

Old place.

My eggplant was cold in the middle and food not hot.

All 5 at table had warm not hot food.

Food was bland and lacking in flavor. Forgot croutons and cheese on a caesar salad. Waitstaff was nice.

I've been going to fenicci's for years and this is my first time having a sub par experience. The food and staff were great. The summer just ended so the wait was a lot longer also they must have sized down their soup dishes. Other than that a great place to stop in

Amazing food. Had the upside down pizza and it didn't disappoint. Desserts were great as well, I'd highly recommend the Limoncello.

My daughter and I found Fenicci's from browsing the internet. She ordered the Maryland Crabcake sandwich and I ordered the Exotic Mushroom pizza. We were both impressed. The pizza, in particular, was amazing with exquisitely combined flavors. So delicious!

Very large portions of delicious Italian food! In existence with some original recipes since 1935. Oldest free-standing restaurant in Hershy, Pa.

My boyfriend and I went on our first date here and we just went back to celebrate getting our first apartment together. Even though it was very busy, the staff was still very attentive and pleasant and the food was amazing as always!

The food was good. The service was friendly. The portions were huge. My boyfriend and I shared a Steamed Clams starter and a Mediterranean Seafood Pasta. We just about managed to finish the food. It was a nice dinner. Thank you!

Great food and even better service. The menu and specials offer great variety and they accommodated my wife and daughter's food allergy to ensure we enjoyed our meal. Highly recommended!