Jimmy's Hilltop Ice Cream and Eatery, Effort PA

Great place. If you're into classic cars, go Wednesday evening for the car show while you enjoy an ice cream treat.

The staff is amazing, efficient and super friendly. Everytime we go their portions are good and everything is delicious and the pricing is fair. It’s our go-to spot!

Staff is very helpful and courteous, ice cream is delicious and there are a huge variety of flavors too! Support local!

Hot dogs, milkshakes, soft serve and lots of flavors of hard ice cream. Generous portions of ice cream available in a dish or small, medium, or large cones. Outdoor picnic table seating under a pavilion.

This my first time here.everytime was good but the only problem is when i got the pup cup it started melting on our way home i wish i had a cover over it or in a better way to get it from here to home but my dog loved it either way lol ill be happy when we sit outside ill definitely be back soon

I absolutely love this place. Came all the way over there from New York! I love jimmy, he’s great. The waffle cones are extremely fresh & jimmy accommodated All me & my sisters needs when it came to the things we wanted. I love it & RECOMMEND IT ALWAYS! The chilli cheese dog was GREAT & my reeces arctic swirl was everything. Come on down, you will not be disappointed. I also had the birthday cake milkshake… amazing!

My brother took my mom and I here for the first time and he git a milkshake and mom n I got that Bailey's icecream cone and let me just say it's delicious also kids and pets friendly. Ty

Amazing food and delicious ice cream. The ice cream choices are overwhelming! Delicious and inexpensive. What else can you ask for?

My first experience at Jimmy’s was exceptional, the food and ice cream were great! Even got a dog biscuit in my puppy’s ice cream! However things changed on our next two visits! On both occasions I ordered a sundae! To call what I received a sundae is beyond disgusting! My sundae consisted of black raspberry ice cream a dollop of whipped cream and a cherry! Umm sorry buddy but that’s not a sundae! On the next visit my boyfriend ordered a hot fudge sundae which we’re pretty sure they forgot the hot fudge as there was barely any hot fudge (again) to pay over $5 for a sundae and not get a sundae is insane! Maybe it was the fact that the employees weren’t trained on exactly how to make a sundae if that’s the case May I suggest some training! Cmon Jimmy you can do better! We won’t be going back guess if
I want an actual sundae I’ll have to drive 15 minutes and go to Big Star

Great place for iced cream. The highschool kids that run the place are always courteous and friendly. Get a dusty road and enjoy the sunset.

Best ice cream ever. My absolute favorite is their banana split, it's so big you probably won't be able to eat the whole thing. The milkshakes are so good and you can get one in any flavor they have. I can't pick a favorite flavor because they are all so good. There's food also which is really good. They even have a pup cup for your dog. There's a cute little boat with swings for the kids to play on. And the prices are so affordable. Definitely a go to place for great ice cream. It's my favorite ice cream place ever.

Jimmy the owner very friendly as well as his help, food delicious my grandchildren love going there for the ice cream and playing on the swings and slide enjoy you won't be disappointed

The best grilled cheese I’ve ever had! French fries were nice and crispy. Cheesesteaks needed more cheese, but were delicious. We didn’t have room for ice cream after our meals, next time we will get ice cream first:)

Nice ice cream shop with a good variety and selection if different flavors. They also serve food, but we only stopped for ice cream with the kids.

Couldn't believe how expensive it was for ice cream.other then that location is great, staff was friendly and the play area for the kids is nice

Yesterday (Sunday August 8th, 2021, they closedst 9.30 PM)
Delicious ice creams and amazing customer service. Congrats to the staff