Kelly's Inn, York PA

The New York strip was pitiful. The snow crab legs were old and overcooked. The Caesar salad was good

I could not find a better place ever if your tired of slop they sell at McDonald's go here its 100 times better

Best seafood in York! Their stuffed mushrooms are literally the best I've ever had too!

It was ok. Not the kellys inn that I remember, not even close. Haven't eaten here in 15 yrs.or more. Just kinda out of the way for us. But I did eat here a lot back in the day.
Sat bar side. Great bar atmosphere. Smoking allowed but wasn't terribly smokey for us non smokers.
Food was meh. I'd maybe get a basket meal, some fries and a drink but go elsewhere for a dinner. Definitely don't get the steak. Drinks were good and the broasted chicken was the best of everything we ordered. Prices are good and in this case you get what you pay for unfortunately. But place was busy so good for them. ***Oh! The menus online are not accurate. No scallops etc and so on, that why we went there in the first place for the seafood.

Great place to get crabs! We traditionally meet my dad here whos from Lancaster every summer and enjoy some fresh hot steamed crabs and they never disappoint.

This place is family friendly to us each time. Love the homemade soups. Daughter loves the Maryland Crab soup. Would go back anytime.

Crabs are summertime fun food for us! Kelly’s is a great place to eat crabs and broasted chicken. It has great atmosphere and our waitress Judy was very polite and attentive. Thank you for an easy great dinner

Celebrated my birthday with family at Kelly's for crabs. Everything was wonderful! Crabs were big, heavy and came out fresh and steaming hot. No missing claws. We also had various sides like soups, fries, clams, oysters - everything was delicious! Service is always friendly and accommodating. Our server regularly checked in on us. Kelly's has become our go-to crab place! Thanks for an excellent Birthday!

Got large steamed crabs last year ate them there along w/ some appetizers, crabs were great.appetizers so so. Ordered large crabs this year for pick up, they brought my crabs right to my car plus the crabs were full and well worth the money!

Hands down, best crabs we have had in a while. We ordered 2 doz large. They were very full and delicious. The waitress was very friendly and made a really great long island.

We were there on a Wednesday evening. Not real busy in the restaurant. Food was excellent.

This neighborhood spot would be great if they would update the dinning area and bar. It so close to our house we would love to be regular customers but its decor is way outdated.

Tonight was my first visit. I chose to check it out on St Patrick's Day. There was live music. Everything was great even though it was a packed house. I'll definitely visit again. I had the crabcake with shrimp. My husband had beer battered fish and chips.

The secret on the hill. Amazing sea food! Employees always make you feel at home. The owners are top-notch. Highly recommend giving this place a try.

My bestie took me out for my birthday here! It is definitely a hidden gem in York, and the food was good.

The soup was delicious and the potato salad was out of this world. My hubby wasn't too impressed with their soft crabs and my son loved his pasta dish. The fried pickles are a must! I think the crab cake was a little bland but it had a lot of crab meat in it.

We got there an hour before they closed and the waitress was rushing us through the service.

Stuck in 80's, nothing has been updated since then. Food not bad, waitress was seriously lacking in customer service.