Mexitaly Brick oven Brewhouse, York PA

I just got shrimp tacos to go and found they were falling apart in the box. Couldn't even pick them up, had to eat them with a fork. I was very disappointed.

She ordered Caesar salad with salmon the salmon was only 4 bites I got lasagna was cold in the middle owner made up for with a free slice of cheesecake every cook has a bad night once in awhile

This place is not great. The staff is unfriendly. Food is subpar. It’s dirty, overpriced. Not one worker greeted me and when they did they were short and impatient because we didn’t realize we were to seat ourselves and not order at the counter anymore. It was not even busy when we came in, so I’m not sure why the staff member at the front was so impatient and rude about us standing there for a second trying to figure out where we needed to go. Definitely only hear awful things about this place and won’t be back

First time going here today, and let me say… the food was amazing! We ordered Loaded Nachos as a starter, and then I got Chipotle Chicken Enchilada’s for my entree. The food was so good and so fresh. Our waitress, Erin, was very kind and great! I will be requesting her next time. So pleased with this place!

They may as well just let you eat the box that they serve the pizza in. This has to be one of the worst pizzas around.

Mexitaly has been one of my hubby's favorite restaurants since it opened and it has become one of mine too. We always get a burrito or tacos and they are always delicious! Pizzas look great too. I've just never ordered one!

I haven't been here in a while and everything is still bloody awesome.
Had the enchilada plate with a cranberry cider. YUMMERS!
I need to learn to take pictures.

Had the ground beef enchilada andy friend had shrimp and scallop enchilada. They said theirs was phenomenal.

Next time we will try some of their Italian dishes.

Give them a try.
Pricing is reasonable and you get a lot.

Also, try their craft beers.yummy, yummy, yummy!

Great food, great atmosphere, great people. Highly recommend the tacos.

Edit: Now they give you even more food than the last time I went. This last visit I got a burrito, even I couldn't finish. Thats a first for me. Highly reccomend, and remember to check out the bar

This place was a stinker.

Steak tacos were dry and flavorless. The cheese had more flavor than the meat. My lettuce was browning.

The black bean soup was unedible. A couple of beans and really really runny broth. Just black water that tasted like lime and cilantro. Gagged in the parking lot.

Also the cook was dicing up raw chicken directly next to cooked chicken. Pratically touching. So foul.

All this for 21 dollars.
Tacos, soup, and a soda. 21 dollars

Just went here for the first time on a double date. The food was great. The service was good. But the manager, and older man, came to our table and was angry we were staying and talking and told us to leave since there was a line waiting for tables. We had no idea there was a line. We would not have stayed and kept talking if we knew we needed to move along. All he needed to do was be kind and could have gotten the same idea across. Because of his anger this great experience became a great disappointment. He was awful.

(Editing below to respond to the owner, who apparently is also the man who was rude.)

Owner, My issue is that 1) we were clueless that people were waiting and enjoying our time. Time was flying and we had no idea how long we were there. None of your staff gave us any hints we were there too long. Where we were seated in the back, we couldn't see anyone waiting. 2) you think you were giving us a gentle nudge, and you didn't. You were rushed and angry. That came out. My point is that your entire staff worked hard, and your restaurant was great, but your attitude towards us was uncalled for. You can disagree all you want. This is how all 4 of us at the table took what and how you said for us to leave.

Went for dinner and drinks with a group of six on a Wednsday night. Despite all the workers, service was a little slow, albeit friendly. Had a few basic beers and they were okay. Chips for apps were stale. Had the seafood enchilada which wasn't that great. It didn't seem baked like a traditional enchilada, but I guess I'm not suprised. Portion size was good, but still a little pricey. The atmosphere was okay and clean. I wouldn't go out of my way to go again, but I don't regret the experience. I think they're trying to do too much.

Straight up have never had a bad meal here. Everything is great. Food portions are excellent for the price. Ingredients are fresh, and the employees are always very friendly. I appreciate the atmosphere.it is clean, not too loud, and it's very spacious, I don't feel like I am sitting on someone's lap (because, ew.).

The favourite things to order are the taco salads (the shell is boss! So good), and the quesadillas. For the beer, I had a bohemian pils the last time I was there, and it was light and refreshing.

Always impressed.

Carole. Absolute best. You don't get this service anymore.

Buritto is excellent. Service is even better.

The food is amazing! If they mess up your order they fix it without attitude. The staff is friendly. The atmosphere is super laid back.

Well I get being busy, but I put my order on line 5 hours ahead and still waited 20 minutes. The food was not packed well in the flimsy bag and the sauces fell out in my truck ad well as the burrito. When I got home IMY wife and I had the $10 rubbery calamari. Just expected more.

Always enjoy lunch here. I got the monster burrito with steak and enjoyed the peach mango sour beer and a blood orange hefeweizen. Everything was delicious!

Our waitress Carol was terrific. Great service and such a wonderful personality!
Delicious food and attentive service.