Old City Bagel Company

Amazing bagels, amazing coffee, amazing baked goods, amazing service! Imagine walking into a cute quant bagel shop with the aroma of fresh brewed coffee and sticky buns right out of the oven=Perfection. I got “The Big Diehl” special on an Oreo bagel, nitro cold brew coffee and a red velvet donut. The Oreo bagel was soft, chewy and toasted perfectly! Anything on Nitro is worth the hype, smooth smooth smooth and less acidic than regular coffee! NOW after tasting a homemade donut I can NEVER go back to the chemical tasting donuts that Dunkin produces. Seriously go try for yourself! Would love to see Old City brand out to the Williamsport area so I can be a daily customer. 10/10 recommend and worth the drive wherever you are coming from!

I'm originally from NYC. The bagels were very good and of quality however I felt they were a bit overpriced. The coffee was better than I expected. Nice atmosphere.

Update 12/15/23: new owners have knocked it out of the park. They are more engaged social media wise and walking through the front door a massive change. Happy to see it succeeding again.

The best bagel! The mix of flavors is great, the ingredients are fresh, the service is fast and the staff is very friendly. The Salmon Bagel is the best! Although I have to go back and try the Avocado one. The Mocha was very delicious.

Out of towner here who was in town for a function. Wanted a cup of coffee and found this little place. A nice little “hole in the wall”, so to speak, busy and smelling bagely. Ordered a plane bagel with the veggie creamed cheese, and a cup of coffee. The coffee was good. A decent cup of joe. The bagel, a nice chew with out being tough, plain and fresh. Now let’s talk about the veggie creamed cheese…. Fresh to death! I have never had it as good. Imagine it if you may; someone is slicing your bagel while a team chop the veggies toss them in the creamed cheese, whipped again, spread generously on your now cut bagel, wrapped up and delivered to you. That is how good it was. Take my word for it but try it yourself. You will not be let down. The Christmas time festive scone was delicious as was the egg nog muffin.

Authentic Bagel made multiple times daily
DELICIOUSLY fresh, with high quality ingredients for a variety of sandwiches

Old City Bagel Company has a nice atmosphere and probably the best bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel I’ve had recently. Was a bit tight inside and not much room for the line to form.

Food and coffee were good, but I asked for my bagel to be extra toasted and it wasn’t toasted at all. Service was slow.

Customer service is horrible. They’ll leave you on hold for 15 minutes, then hang up on you.

It was fine. The bagel was kinda bland. It was blueberry but tasted plain. The employee was nice!

So dirty, I don't think this place has ever seen a mop and it kinda smells like sweaty feet. A plain bagel took an absurd amount of time and was stale. Also paid for cream cheese and received no cream cheese? !? Owner was rude and unhelpful and also smelled like feet. Don't waste your time and money in this joint.