Original Italian Pizza, Millville PA

Very poor service. Ordered at 450pm food finally showed up at 640pm food was cold.nothing but excuses and attitude from the manager. Manager started yelling over the phone saying that we should just appreciate the cold food and they he isnt a slave. Will NEVER ORDER FROM THEM AGAIN!

Great staff, They know me and they know how I like my pizza, especially the calzone and they always do a great job lol. A family buisness run by authentic Italians. My fiance loves their homemade bread. They offer delivery, be sure to call ahead of time because especially in the winter they do get busy. Definitely recommend.

Our food was average. My daughter's pizza was gross. Service was good though and prices were fair.

We ordered cold subs to go! They were very good, fresh Ingredients, quality cheese. Fast service and the young gal was pleasant who took our order. Ashame we have drove by this place so often. We absolutely will be making this OIP a stop in our travels. Thank you for providing a excellent product. By the way, they had plenty of help and everyone was working hard.

OIP used to be a good inexpensive place. But however which makes me unhappy is that they started charging $3 for everybody. I live 1 block away from the restaurant. But their gonna charge me $3. The same as someone that lives out of town. And I'm sure their losing alot of customers. Cause where I live. People always ordered from them but not anymore they dont. Since they started charging a delivery fee for a block away. Forget that I'll go to berwick OIP and plus its also cheaper.

Great food. Absolutely wonderful service. Great place to take the family for dinner or just to stop for a slice.

So we stopped here to take food for my Uncle's BDay & I'm so happy that we did. This place is AMAZING! Best meatball sub I have ever had in my life.full of fresh made huge meatballs that were quartered to fit in the most delicious soft homemade bread I have had. They do not skimp on the cheese either. We ended up eating one because it was so big and full of meatball & cheese. Honestly I would drive the hour and half to get their food again. They are true Italians, very hospitable & good looking to boot! If you are within a hour distance of this place I guarantee it is worth the trip for true Italian food. I can't wait to try the pizza, I heard it's great!

Absolutely amazing! Best Stromboli that I have had. Got the meat lovers and it was loaded. Will be back for more. Staff was very friendly and helpful too.

I stop here almost every time I head to my cabin in Sullivan County. I love there food alot. Always have great pizza and sandwiches. The service has always been great. I know I will be back soon

Pizza very good, piping hot and ready right on time. Staff friendly and polite. Excellent!

I love this restaurant. The food is so good and portions are huge. Plus the boss and employees are absolutely amazing

So I visited my mom for the holiday and she was in the mood for pizza, I had the California burger she had a pineapple slice, I have to tell you I'm from New York and it was probably one of the best burgers I've had, definitely top five! Thank you!

This place is the picturesque setting for the typical thought of a rural family diner. It is small and cozy, “outdated” enough in style that it doesn’t feel stuffy but is still kept up with, and very homey. The menu is extensive! It took me awhile to narrow down my dinner, but I don’t think I could’ve gone wrong no matter what I chose. Oh, and you get heaps of (deliciously made with love) food for the price. My cheesesteak took two meals to finish! And was an absolute delight to eat (for just under $9, I believe it was?). I certainly plan to return.

My wife and I had a superb experience dining at your establishment this evening. Staff was friendly and our waitress was delightful.

Had a little issue with delivery tonight, had to pick up ourselves after calling to find the delivery vehicle broke down, Phil (owner) was very good about it gave the delivery and tip money back and fresh food also apologized for the issue and recognized he should have called, but they were very busy, thanks Phil you are good people

We love ordering from our hometown OIP. Always friendly staff, awesome food and good prices!

My family ordered food last night, hour and a half passes we call to see what's going on with it. We were told "they left over 20 minutes ago with 4 other orders". Half an hour later they finally show up, food was cold and soggy and 2 of the items weren't even right. No excuse for sending a delivery driver with 4 orders especially when they aren't in close proximity and its hot food.

Phil the owner good buddy of mine whole family from italy works there
Awesome food dine in or take out

They sit on a throne of lies! The owner is from Sicily, not Italy. This is false advertising! But seriously, this is the best pizza you're going to find between Pittsburgh and NYC. Phillip, Rosa, and Joseph put all their love into making the best food. Phillip tenderly kisses each pepperoni and sprinkles a bit of oregano before perfectly placing on a bed of mozzarella, family secret pizza sauce, and artisanal dough, blessed by the Archbishop of Philadelphia. Rosa holds every fresh loaf of bread from the oven like a baby and says a brief prayer. Joseph makes perfect fried cauliflower at the deep fryer whilst simultaneously keeping a soccer ball in the air with is head. I once killed a man because he took a bite of my cheesesteak while I was using OIPs cleanest restroom in the county. Phillip graciously called some guys to take care of the body.

Food: we’ve eaten here four times now in the last year. Two were dine-in and two were take away. We’ve never had a single thing that we wouldn’t order again. The Stromboli (meat lover) is my favorite and there is enough for three meals (2 leftovers the next two days).

Staff: are always polite and attentive. We wouldn’t change or ask for anything different.

Support the local places! Thank you.