P&J Pizza, Elizabethtown PA

I ordered a cheesesteak and a salad with bleu cheese dressing. They didn’t include the dressing in the bag or on the salad. When I called, the girl said I didn’t ask for dressing. I told her that I did and what kind I wanted. This is the second time they screwed up my salad order. I will walk the extra distance to go somewhere else. I’m done.

Always a great experience for me at this local Italian place. Good service + pizza, specialties, and their homemade bread is amazing dining in or taking out. Long time patron, you won't be disappointed either!

Wife and I went to the little oddities museum and decided to come here for lunch the cheesesteak were really good and the bread was very fresh and thick enough that it didn’t get soggy and fall apart before you can finish the onion rings and curly cheese fries are also very good.

This is the best pizza ever! From the crust to the sauce to the fresh toppings. P and J Special pizza is the ticket.

I would like to start off by saying there food is amazing! There fresh bread, rolls and pizza is outstanding! The only thing I complain about is the following. Ham puffs are on the menu, but if the owner is working the front or he answers the phone, he will say we don't have them right now! Errrr! Smh! Anyone else answers the phone or is working the front he makes them for me. I always try to order 6 or more. I've had this happen so many times now that I've lost count now. It's ALOT!

We ALWAYS get just "a plain cheese pie", because we're from N. Y
and that's everyone ordered. It's how you gauge a pizza! P&J's rated a solid 5 stars! They make an outstanding lg. Cheese pie!?

Good food but if you ask for moderations they will mess it up every single time. THREE TIMES IN A ROW we have ordered cheeseburger subs with no mayo and they consistently come with mayo on them

P&J's eggplant parm sandwich is the first I've ever had, and man what an awesome first impression. The bread & sauce were delicious, plus it was fresh and hot. My fiance got a pepperoni stromboli that he loved, as well! Ordering delivery from this place for the first time through DoorDash made me somewhat skeptical (just because we've had a few issues with other places), but they followed the special instructions to a tee and everything was well-packaged. We will absolutely be back!

This place actually makes banging pizza. The best part is that he didn't have any slices. But what the guy behind the counter said was I'll make another one. And hooked me and my boys up with slices. Cheers brother. Here's to Latinos making better pizza than the Italians.

I was hungry for a good sub. Their bread is good. I ordered a special Italian sub. They toasted toasted it the lettuce on it.

.

The food was good. The people are friendly. The only thing that really bothered me was the trash cans were super full in the dining area and the women's bathroom. With trash all over the floor, it was a stomach turner.

Giuseppe is THE MAN! Great pizza, fast service, generous salads! You got to try the Sicilian Special! My whole team loved our lunch today! @etownflooring

The saltiest pizza I’ve ever tasted in my life pizza literally has no flavor but salt. There’s a lot of pizza in Elizabethtown just do yourself a favor and skip this one.

Called to order pizza, the guy on the phone was very short with me and when i picked up the pizza the order was wrong. I didnt realize it was wrong until i walked out of the store and the guy immediately closed 30 minutes early. Pizza was spectacular tho.

We are at the KOA campground in Elizabethtown/Hershey and had Doordash deliver pizza, salad and other things.everything on time and delicious

Everyone in E-town knows they have the best subs, and the pizza is pretty damn good to. So I guess this is for people from out of town. You have to try these guys! I believe you'll love their food, and will come back to E-town just for it, if you have no other reason to visit.

Food is good however when I opened my cheesesteak there was no sauce. My fiance is highly upset

In our experience, best pizza in Elizabethtown! Fast service. Fresh ingredients. Great crust! We love this place!

Like usual I had 1 sandwich made special for my wife and a large pizza. Got there and when I got home my wife was happy, her steak sandwich was just like I ordered and my daughter loved her pizza. The steak sandwich I ordered a large and that was a very big sandwich. Happy customers.