Tomato Pie Cafe, Lititz PA

A varied seasonal menu with reasonable prices. Service is excellent. Dining areas are small but comfortable. Food was delicious with unique items such as the delicious Tomato Pie and Spagetti Squash Cakes. The Pumpkin scone with brown butter was excellent.

An ever so popular lunch spot in Lititz, so I was excited to try Tomato Pie on a busy Saturday afternoon. Unfortunately, the food does not live up to the line you see waiting outside. My turkey burger was dry, like cardboard, and the pretzel roll it was served on was cardboard, as well.

The servers are mostly always fairly Kurt, efficient, but could be friendlier. The owner is super friendly.

What a perfect place to eat in a perfect little town. You feel like you have traveled into the past. The food and service was very good. The namesake tomato pie is a must have.

Don't care I deliver food from this place. The staff makes drivers wait when the food is ready.

Lovely and quaint cafe with really great seasonal items like an autumn salad and maple and cardamom latte. Their coffee is strong and their food is hearty while their staff was welcoming and friendly. Totally recommend!

Damn Good. Tomato Pie is an experience. It’s laid back, quaint atmosphere. All round good food. Killer (probably the best in Lititz, arguably Lancaster) cup of coffee, drip, latte, or specialty drink. Breakfast is my personal favorite time to go.

Weekends there can be a bit of a wait, just prepare a little ahead and you’ll be good to go.

Also: Brookes is a fire barista. Dude knows how to pull a shot.

Ordered the pancakes and they were burnt black. I was shocked they were let go from the kitchen like that.

Second time and the food, service and drinks did not disappoint! Would pay more for the quality we reviewed!

Great staff, great food, great coffee, and a wonderful patio on a crisp Fall Sunday morning. Definitely recommend the Pumpkin Pancakes!

I want to send a big THANK YOU shout out to TPC staff and patrons! Today I took my friend to visit Lititz who has difficulty walking. The attentiveness to her needs exceeded my expectations and provided a wonderful experience. A sincere thanks!

First time trying a spinach artichoke tomato pie- delicious! Husband said the egg flipper, aka omelette was the best!

Their signature dish is really excellent. The lemonade has surgical sugar which is odd for a place with natural ingredients everywhere else. Indoor ambience is pleasant and not loud.

I ordered breakfast from here on 9/25/20
Very subpar. 18$ for a scramble egg sandwich with about 8 very small pieces of sausage and 4 tablespoons of home fries. With 2 small lattes. I wont be going here again.
Lattes were good.