Victor's Italian Restaurant, York PA

Wow! What a fantastic restaurant. Everything was a 10 from the service to the drinks, appetizer, dinner and dessert. Risotto was out of this world. Spare Rib Tortellini divine. Gouda fondue superb. You must try the Victors Cleanse cocktail and the apple crisp Crème Brûlée is a must. 10 out of 10.

For $36, I expect to be able to taste the salmon over the charcoal, but it was not the case. The broccoli served with it was also burned. Our waitress was kind and the live music was nice, but food is integral to a good restaurant experience. It’s a bit insulting that the chef thought they could serve something that burnt to someone.

OMFG! Simply amazing! Its pricey but WORTH IT! Came out for my birthday and had drinks, food, dessert, and dessert drinks. Not a single item dissaponted. And even when we had a hard time deciding our waitress gave her opinion and it was not wrong. On top of that McKenzie (our waitress) was absolutely wonderful; on top of everything, friendly, funny, helpful and quick! 10 out of 10 recommend for any special occassion!

Had several things off the menu, all was delicious! Great wine and drink selection as well! Come hungry. The food is very filling and tasty.

Wonderful veal marsala, bartender was very attentive and friendly. Very cozy and relaxing atmosphere, I wish there was a restaurant like this back home

Wonderful dinner, delicious flavors. My husband had the halibut special entrée and myself the veal parmesan- one of their classic dishes. Plus, my glass of red recommended by the server could not have paired better with the dish. Was never big on Italian before my friend told my husband and me to check it out for date night. Can’t wait to try their patio seating!

Had a really good first experience at this Italian restaurant. It’s an old church converted to a restaurant and offers a lot of character. I had the shrimp and clams in the white sauce with gluten-free pasta. Catered very well to a gluten-free diet and had a few different offerings. I did the gluten-free pasta, which was delicious but they also offer a spiral zucchini as an option that I will certainly be back for. Everything was great, but the highlight was our server! Manh, provided one of the absolute best experiences I’ve had in a pretty long time. She’s personable, knowledgeable and offers an experience that you’ll wanna go back for. Highly recommend this restaurant!

Had dinner with friends and family on Wednesday and the meal, service and beverages were just perfection. There was something for everyone of all ages and dietary requirements.

First tume in York, PA, and this is where I found myself, Old church turned into restaurant, and it was a great Valentine eve night

This place is amazing! Its our favorite restaurant in York! Delicious food, great ambience, and good people! We love it!

Was there tonight for the first time. Jillian was our server. She recommended the sea bass on special & omg it was awesome! My date had the chicken parmigiana. We were very happy. Jillian was an excellent server. Beautiful inside & out! We will be back!

Wonderful hidden gem in York!

We went here twice already, and my husband loves it. It's a little higher-end Italian restaurant, but it's so good. Amazing food, great service, great atmosphere overall. I got the Alpine chicken for a special a few months ago, and it was delicious. It was a little more expensive than I would normally pay, but it was totally worth it and it was so unique and deliciously made. See picture of the dish!

My husband's dish was also amazing as well. He got it the second time we went there. He got the short rib risotto - it is so high quality and scrumptious. We also love the complimentary bread they provide. We'll definitely be back.

First restaurant my wife and I visited after moving here and I have to say I was hands down impressed! The staff was great, food amazing, and the atmosphere was something out of a movie. We will DEFINITELY be visiting again as it is now saved as one of my favorites. If you plan to attend on a weekend make reservations.

Extra: Our waitress told us there is Jazz on Fridays and every now and then there are live music events they hold.

Do yourself a favor and put this location on your "must visit" list, you won't regret it.

I can't say it enough. Best food in york, suggest it to everyone I meet. Their soups never disappoint and their frequent menu changes keep things interesting. Well done

First time there, took our 10yr old daughter with. Got a hightop so we could get in before the Saturday dinner crowd. Didn’t get her name, but the waitress was great with our daughter and us. Food was fantastic.best Italian wedding soup i’ve ever had.we got the sea bass special and the salmon risotto for main course. We will be back soon and won’t leave without dessert!

I must say this is my favorite place to dine in York county. I have many memories many meals ate, wine drank and hearts won. The food is excellent some of the finest service.