Pie Society, San Marcos TX

Pizza was delicious.
I came in about 6: 30pm and the pizza was hot and tasty. Staff was kind and attentive. And the Pinot Noir was just super good.

Went tubing and found this place after. Highly recommend it to anyone. Super great atmosphere!

This is a great meet up place! The plaza this place is in is pretty small which gets packed pretty fast so be aware. The place wasn’t crazy big and we arrived at 11: 30 for lunch and I’m glad we did cause it started filling up. The staff was super friendly though, answered all the questions I had since it was my first time in. Basically when you enter you find your seat then head to the front bar to place your order. No waiters just staff in general delivering your food and beer if you ordered it. They also had soda, tea and water. I enjoyed their blueberry soda. We ordered a pepperoni slice, Balance of power pie, the pyramid pizza toppings and added fennel sausage made into a calzone and the 78-666 pizza toppings made into a calzone. My pyramid calzone was super delicious and big so leftovers for sure. Tons of cheese so chew chew chew so you don’t choke haha. Everyone in my party enjoyed their food and complimented on how good it was so we have zero complaints. Things to note only one stall restroom for men and women but was nice and clean. Would definitely go back for sure.

Bought a pizza in Feb that was burnt then bought one today that hardly had any toppings on it. I’m done.

This little 'conspiracy theory' place is unbelievable. The decor is unique and enjoyable. Staff was friendly and fun. The pies were amazing, for real fantastic pizza. The drink choices were different, fun and yummy. Blueberry soda, I mean come on.

We were greeted immediately and introduced to the establishment. Had wonderful service by Bailey, and River! The pyramid pizza was amazing and you can order by the slice several different types before 8! The dough was not too salty but made the crust thin and crispy. The restaurant was clean and comfortable! We will come again!

We were there on Thursday 6/23. We were there put of town on a baseball tournament and found this quaint and cute establishment. We ordered The Handshake and a cheese calzone. The cheese calzone was the size of both my hands put together. The pizza was the best we have had in a long time. It was piping hot and the cheese was ooey-gooey. The ingredients were so fresh. The pictures don't do it justice. Wished we had this establishment in my area.

Probably one of the worst places in town for time management and customer service. The first time my boyfriend and I tried the place it was a busy Thursday evening, next to the college and chalked it up to just being overwhelmingly busy.
However, we recently decided to give them another chance. The food was great the first time and so terrible wait times and even worse customer service, could be forgiven.
This time we decided to order ahead and pick it up, thinking maybe giving them a a heads up will help them. Nope. Not even one bit. My boyfriend goes to pick up order and is ignored and stared at by employees who can’t be bothered. When someone finally decides to acknowledge his presence, he is rudely interrogated about the order. And then is told it’s not ready, even though their text said it was. For upwards of 40 minutes he waits at the restaurant waiting for our dinner which should have been done by 9: 01pm. And then is still being treated rudely.
Never again will we be visiting Pie Society and we will be vocal about never visiting there to friends and family and others in the community so they don’t have to wait an eon for a meatball sub and calzone.

This was our first visit to PS. All the reviews implied that they had the best pizza in town. Well.the beer was good. We got a split pie: one side with sausage and the other with pepperoni, green peppers (never got on) garlic, onions. The pizza had little to no sauce, minimal veggies, sparse meat but HEAVY garlic. The crust though was good. We also got a Caesar salad. It was a good salad but again, a heavy hand with the garlic which rendered the salad a bit unpleasant to eat. We love garlic but this was too much. I am sorry to say but it was disappointing. We will continue to search for somewhere local (Austin's Via 313 is some of the best we ever had but not local) that actually have good pizza.

Honestly probably one of the best pizza places in town hands down. The balance of power is always our go to. Workers and staff are always nice too.

It's a really good pizza place but they always take forever on the to go orders. Best pizza in town but it isn't worth it to wait 2 hours when gumbys is done is good to go in 20 min

Pizza was reminiscent of New York pizza. Crust was crispy with just a little bit of cheweyness. Ingredients were fresh. Great atmosphere with high ceilings and plenty of space.

Love, love their pizza, best around! Everyone there is so nice. Last time there I got to-go and on my way out my salad went flying. They came out to help me and made me a new one.

The Strawberry Goat cheese salad was good. They were sold out of Garlic knots and after waiting 40 minutes for our pizza, we saw that it was sitting while to-go and delivery orders took priority. We never actually got to try it.sadly, it looked amazing!

Food is good. Services were also adequate. Save for one of the front of house boys. While his pony tail and eyeliner had me believing at first that he would be approachable.
The entire time we were deciding what to order he rushed us. And trying to make any conversation was met with blatantly disrespectful dismissal.
Will not be going again.

We ordered our pizzas at 6: 19pm and it is now 7: 19pm and still no pizza. When asked about it two different times they said it was in the oven. If this was true those pizzas are burnt to a crisp. Manager never came over to apologize or talk to us. Also, the entire staff touched all the pizzas they were making with their bare hands. Then one of wait staff say me writing the review and said how can you rate us a one star when you haven't even tasted the pizza. Perhaps its because we still hadn't got the pizza over an hour. Really?