Gemelli Gelato of Hampton Bays

Cash only, and well worth the stop. The owner is friendly and each scoop is served with a side of good cheer. The Gelato is not too creamy, not too dense, and the flavors were outstanding. I tried the pumpkin spice and the rum raisin. Next time, I'm going to have to get one of the flavored waffle cones.

The gelato was amazing with so many flavors to choose! The atmosphere is beautiful, enabling everyone to sit outside with many different types of seating. I have to give an extra shout out to the owner and employee, who went above and beyond to help me with my son who uses a motorized wheelchair. I will definitely go back many times, even though it’s a ride from Nassau, it’s too good not to go back!

Tiny place dirty, they accept only cash and very expensive, 6$ for a small supermarket ice cream. SCAM!

Best. Gelato. On. Long Island. Period.
Try the strawberry Nutella or the elephant mixture.

Great Gelato! The staff and owner were very patient and friendly. Highly recommend! They also had allergy friendly options! Thank you!

Great tasting Gelato. Càsual relaxing environment. Sit and enjoy the wonderful lawn area as you snack on your frozen treats. Lots of parking

Was so happy to try this Gelato with my family. Everyone really enjoyed the flavors. The staff were patient and let us sample a bunch. I believe the place is cash only. Super smooth and tasty!

The place is very small but if your into Gelato this is the place to go.
They have certain flavors that are always available and then every day there are one or two specials. The front is spacious and lots of chairs to get comfy with your family or loved ones.

Stopped by last year but couldn't get anything bc we didn't realize it was cash only. Finally got to stop here again this summer and on a weekday so it was much less busy. The gentleman helping us was very friendly and nice. Portions were very generous and he made our cones look good for the gram! The mango and strawberry are delicious and they have a great wide selection of cones too. Thank you again for having us.

One of the best gelato’s we have had in New York/Hamptons (all 6 of us agree). The texture is so smooth and creamy. We came here twice on a weekend and we thoroughly enjoyed their flavors. We had their banana, pistachio, chocolate, strawberry and coffee gelato in their cute cones which they outsource from a lady in Brooklyn and the cones were really tasty. We tried their lavender cone, their red velvet one and also their cinnamon brown sugar cone - everything was amazing. Their blood orange sorbet was off the charts too!

Cute spot!

Yummy! Great gelato! Awesome flavored cones! Great service! We will return to try the lavender cone!

Gemelli just opened and we are so happy. They have delicious Gelato. The owners are so kind and they always go out of the way to be nice to our children. We love the chocolate elephant in a toasted coconut waffle cone. We look forward to going on the nights they have live music! Thanks Gemelli!

Had salted carmel, not rich in texture or flavor. The coffee gelato tasted like burnt coffee. Save your $

Delicious smooth and creamy. Best gelato ever! Had the banana Nutella and pb. You won't be disappointed.

We had Gemelli Gelato come to our Wedding to surprise our guests! They all raved about the gelato (which I knew they would, being a Gemelli Gelato lover myself). It was so unique and fun! We chose our 5 favorite flavors: Lemon Cookie, Peach Almond Crumble, Chocolate Elephant (which has peanut butter and chocolate in it), Mint-Oreo, and Pistachio.

My FRIEND took me there, oh my god, simply the best I have ever had since my visit to Italy.

PROS:
-large selection of flavors
-cute atmosphere
-plenty of parking

CONS:
-terribly mediocre ice cream (tried 6+ different flavors)
-cash only (ATM inside though!)

Cash only.

A nice mix of interesting flavors and the regulars.

Excellent outdoor seating area.