Gerry Tull's Store, Endicott NY

Excellent place! Got a beautiful Christmas tree from them for a reasonable price! Staff is amazing

My family and I order subs often from here as it is a quick convenient location to our home and all my kids have sports so often times were eating a late dinner and it needs to be quick. However EVERY SINGLE TIME we get subs from there the bread is completely cut thru the subs fall apart and are extremely destroyed basically. Wayyyyyy to much meat on the sub which wouldn't be a bad thing if bigger rolls were used it to much. It's a disaster everytime we order from here. Tonight especially every single sub was cut through both sides of the bread. This will be my last time ordering from here I basically pay 50$ for slop wrapped up in parchment paper.

They steal money out of employees paychecks/tips on top of the owner abusing his employees.they also just buy their merchandise from other stores (ex: Aldi) and then sell it for a ridiculous markup ed cost.they also recently lost their health inspection rating so careful eating anything from there.there is also a cashier who has a terrible attitude with horrible hygiene with pink hair and bed bugs/roaches

Cannot comment on the ice cream but do not order a tuna melt here, many years in business but fail to make a tuna melt
Ive attached directions for reference, good luck

Stir together everything in a bowl, mixing it well, leaving the mayonnaise for last. Add mayonnaise a spoonful at a time, just enough to bind everything together. The salad should hold its shape on a spoon. (You can make the tuna salad up to three days ahead. Store covered and refrigerated. Drain off any accumulated liquid and stir well before using.)

Cover one side of each bread slice with butter or mayonnaise, spreading it all the way to the edges. Turn the slices over and cover with cheese, either sprinkling it or tearing the pieces to fit. Top with tuna salad.

Close the sandwiches and cook on a griddle or in a large skillet over medium-high heat until deep golden brown and crisp, about 3 minutes per side, pressing lightly with the spatula. Serve immediately.

The lady’s in the store were very nice. As for the prick counting bottles in the shed, this is where I draw the line. I asked the old man if he wanted me to count the bottle, I had just picked them up from someone’s house (meaning I had no idea what was gonna be in the bags) the man said no he will do it. I guess there was fur dumped in one. He came out with an attitude threw the dirt/fur at me and said “clean” bottles, I tried to explain they weren’t from my house. Then stormed inside, came back about again and showed me crushed bottles saying that these don’t count. I lost it, i snapped back reminding him, I offered to count the bottle, they weren’t from my effing home and I had no idea what was in there. He asked me to stop swearing gathered up my bottles and returned them back to me. Yeah I get it, the bags should’ve been cleaned but I offered to count them and he said just bring them in. Super disrespectful and clearly hates his job.

Stopped in first time today. Grabbed 2 fresh subs and we will be back! Great customer service and it was delicious.

This place always has great stuff. They carry Hershey's ice cream, so definitely stop here if you are in the area and want to get a treat. It is much better than Perry's, etc. I do not stop in as often as I should, but they have continued to be great over the decades.

Have never been but I've heard good things about Tully's and will visit in the future.

Love the subs! But gotta wonder what happened to your pickles? The last several times I've gotten one, the pickles taste more like straight cucumbers than pickles. That's enough to disappoint this dill pickle lover

We played mini golf, then ate subs and ice cream. The mini golf was fun and the subs and ice cream were delicious!

Old time family run store & more, it always smells Soo good inside, turkey, pulled pork, and more. Mini golf, ice cream, and bottle return.

They have a wide variety of basic needs for your fridge. The valso have great Ice Cream. Friendly staff.

Great little General store, alittle bit of everything. Even a bottle return building for ease of returns.

Their subs are good and very reasonable. They are very friendly and put their customers first! They make the best shakes!

Interesting place, look like a lot of fun in the summer. Most outdoor stuff shut down for the winter.

This place is horrible anymore I refuse to take cans back or even order there subs anymore it use to be a great little sub place and I never had any problems taking my cans there definitely has changed for the worse