Magic Fountain, Mattituck NY

This is the best ice cream in Suffolk County! The staff is super knowledgeable and friendly, and can whip up any flavor you want if it’s not on the menu. They do birthday cakes as well! Doggy treats? They got them! If you’re in the mood for ice cream. This is the only place to visit.

Doesn't matter if it's middle of the night, 20 below zero, they've got a line out the door. Almond Joy ice cream, you know you want it!

Delicious ice cream. Highly recommend their sampler pack. Try something new while you are here. It will be worth it. There can be some wait. It is part of the experience. If you want to skip the wait, you can also order ahead via their website.

Absolutely amazing experience, with amazing staff! I’m was so happy to see an allergy chart and ingredient list with all the food allergies, and was amazed at how natural and healthy the ice cream was! Portion size was very well done, and will go again soon!

Magic Fountain is the best ice cream I’ve ever had
A staple of the Northfork
Hands down better than snowflake

Best ice cream ever. Been going there for15 years since we moved to Mattituck. But the last two times we were there the portions have become so small on the 2 scoop sunday and the girl put on about a tablespoon of hot fudge. Hopefully the next time will be better.

Not only amazing creamy ice cream but they made it so easy for us to navigate my son’s nut and egg allergies. What a great find!

I Come here every summer I really like the ice cream but the line is normally horrendously long but it does move quite quick I would give five stars but sometimes the ice cream will be practically melted after being outside for 3 minutes but I have nothing else bad to say

A must-visit ice cream shop! Homemade and local flavors, two tasting spoons, and the friendly staff had enough patience to appease my over-excited kids.

Very deserving as a local favorite. I always have to hit it up whenever I'm on the North Fork. Kinda pricey I guess but really tasty and interesting flavors.

Delicious. Line was super long but moved. Took about 40 minutes. My ice cream was fantastic.

Best ice cream on the northfork with options for everyone. Only complaint is the parking. It's horrendous

1st time I came here last month. Great flavors and product. Portion was good. Today me and wife ordered 2 scoops. Portion was small. More like one and a quarter scoops server was rude not a great experience. Overpriced for small Portion.

We have passed this place so many times that we finally said let's try it. They usually have a line in the warmer weather, but since this was off-season, we said what the heck. I had two scoops of pistachio with brown sprinkles, and my daughter had cotton candy with rainbow sprinkles. However, the strangest thing happened when I practically went to the bottom of the cone, which took me no time, I had found that the ice cream was like a slimline green and that it was very sticky. I am not sure what it was, but thankfully, it was at the bottom. I showed it to my wife, and she's like, there's nothing left. I said I know, it was good, but I'm not sure what that is. So I threw it out. May be it was just freezer burn? However, my daughter likes the cotton candy ice cream.

Absolutely the BEST ice cream anywhere! The owner is the nicest man… I was late in ordering my husband’s birthday cake and the owner whipped up a beautiful cake just in time. I’ll always be grateful for this as well as many years of bringing family squeals when the word “ice cream? ” is whispered!