McClary's Ice Cream Stand, Cayuta NY

Prices are good. Ice cream selection isn't the biggest but enough to find something you'll like. There was only two people working at the time we where there. It was pretty busy and a good size line. However it did move at a good pace. Lots of seating. I got the Caribbean Sunday. Pretty good.

Good experience. We had basic soft-serve, which was good and very reasonably priced, but they also had lots of creative ice cream options. Several picnic tables available

Wasn't fond of the chocflavor in their milkshake. Tasted like a cheaper flavoring than other shops I frequent.

Yum yum yum! Great selection, including gluten free and dairy free, as well as massive dairy and sugar for those of us who are more traditional

Usually get a Sunday or soft serve, never disappointed. They're only open until 9pm, and this year they're closed after September 19.

I had the Grasshopper Sundae and it was phenomenal! The employee was very awesome as well.

Awesome sundaes and flavor selection of SOFT SERVE & hard ice cream. Seriously, who has flavors other than chocolate and vanilla in soft serve? KILLING IT!

An institution. Has been around almost 50 years that I know of. My favorite place for ice cream!

Beautiful shop! Always great service. Lots of seatling and plenty of parking with tons and tons of options! Ice

Great variety of options of both hard and soft ice cream. The signs say they are cash only do be prepared.

We ordered ice cream there today and it was super good. I got the peach cobbler sundae and requested to pay for an extra biscuit. This woman straight up told me no and shook her head saying I specifically can only have one biscuit hahahah. We left there laughing but I really did want that biscuit. So you can have 3 stars.